Fed Paper: Power of Technical Analysis in Forex is Declining

Being a practitioner of fundamental analysis, you could say that I’m always on the lookout for hard evidence that fundamental analysis is superior to technical analysis. Thus, I was delighted to discover a working paper (“Technical Analysis in the Foreign Exchange Market“) by the St. Louis Branch of the Federal Reserve Bank, released just this month. Alas, the paper barely touched upon fundamental analysis, but its conclusions on technical analysis in the currency markets were startling. In short, the effectiveness of technical analysis in the currency markets has declined steadily since the 1970s, such that only the most sophisticated/complicated strategies are currently profitable.

Rather than conduct original research, the report’s authors – Christopher J. Neely, an assistant vice president and economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, and Paul A. Weller, the John F. Murray Professor of Finance at the University of Iowa – performed a meta analysis of the existing research. They cited a litany of studies, covered a variety of topics, sometimes with contradictory conclusions. In order to ensure comprehensiveness, they looked at the profitability of numerous types of technical analysis indicators, across numerous currency pairs, over time, in different types of trading environments, and adjusted for risk.

All of the earlier studies, dating back to the 1960s, established the profitability of technical analysis, even when it was simplistic. Since then, however, most studies have shown steadily declining effectiveness: “TTRs [Technical Trading Rules] ere able to earn genuine risk-adjusted excess returns in foreign exchange markets at least from the mid-1970s until about 1990…and that rule profitability has been declining since the late 1980s.” The same trend has unfolded in the last decade, as traders have relied increasingly on computerized trading strategies: “Kozhan and Salmon (2010), using high frequency data, find that trading rules derived from a genetic algorithm were profitable in 2003 but that this was no longer true in 2008.”

Given that the two authors also concede that the financial markets are undoubtedly inefficient and that currency markets in particular are filled with observable trends, how should we understand this decline in the effectiveness of technical analysis? In one word, the answer is competition. “Profit opportunities will generally exist in financial markets but…learning and competition will gradually erode ["arbitrage away"] these opportunities as they become known.” In addition, there has been a “dramatic rise in the volume of algorithmic trading,” which has given rise to a so-called financial arms race to develop ever-more sophisticated trading strategies.

Indeed, the research shows that “more complex strategies will persist longer than simple ones. And as some strategies decline as they become less profitable, there will be a tendency for other strategies to appear in response to the changing market environment.” In addition, technical analysis that is used to trade exotic (i.e. less liquid) currencies is more likely to be profitable than major currencies, especially the US Dollar.

The report opens the door to further research, by indicating that “Technical trading can be consistently profitable in certain circumstances.” As if it wasn’t already clear, though, the vast majority of technical traders (perhaps all traders for that matter) are destined to be outmaneuvered and will ultimately lose money trading forex. Another way of looking at this, however, is that the the savviest traders – those that can spot complex trends and execute trading strategies quickly – still have a chance at earning consistent profits.

View the original article here

Swiss Franc Surges to Record High(s)

In the last two weeks, the Swiss Franc rose to record highs against not one, not two, but three major currencies: the US Dollar, Euro, and British Pound. The Franc is now entrenched well above parity against the Dollar, and is closing in on the magical level of 1:1 against the Euro. With market uncertainty projected to run well into 2011, continued strength in the Franc is all but assured.

The Franc’s rise is due entirely to its being perceived as a safe haven currency. Its debt levels are comparable to other industrialized countries, its economy is in mediocre shape, and interest rates are the lowest in the entire world (the overnight lending rate is a paltry .1%). Some analysts have cited the “strong Swiss economic outlook” and “the health of Swiss public finances” as two factors buttressing its strength, but make not mistake: if not for the tide of risk aversion sweeping through the world’s financial markets, the Franc would hardly be attracting any attention.

As I have reported recently, the Dollar and the Yen have also benefited from the spike of risk aversion caused by renewed concerns over the fiscal health of the EU and the prospect of conflict in Korea. Perhaps owning to nothing more than proximity, the Franc has been the primary beneficiary from EU sovereign debt crisis. “It appears that smart money investors are pre-emptively bailing funds out of the eurozone with Switzerland providing a safe port to ride out the eurozone sovereign debt storm that appears to loom on the horizon,” summarized one analyst.

Unfortunately, it looks like the situation in the EU can only become serious. Despite a collective move towards fiscal austerity, all of the problem countries are still running budget deficits. As a result, members of the EU are set to issue no less than €500 Billion of new debt in 2011. To make matters worse, “The onslaught of credit warnings and downgrades of sovereign ratings over the past few days added to worries that borrowing costs in many euro zone nations could rise further.” This could trigger a self-fulfilling descent towards default and further buoy the Franc.

As far as I can tell, the notion that, “Despite the Swiss franc’s recent sharp gains, we still believe there is plenty of room for further upside ahead,” seems to encapsulate current market sentiment. According to the most recent Commitment of Traders Report, investors continue to increase their long positions in the Franc. According to Bloomberg News, “Options traders are more bullish on the franc for the next three months than any major currency except the yen.” Meanwhile, a sample of analysts’ forecasts suggests that the Franc could appreciate another 5% over the next six months.

At this point, the main variable the Swiss National Bank (SNB), which could resume intervention on behalf of the Franc. After spending close to €200 Billion to depress the Franc, the SNB accepted the futility of its efforts and formally renounced intervention in June. However, Swiss National Bank President Philipp Hildebrand recently referred to the Franc’s rise as a “burden,” and warned that the SNB “would take the measures necessary to ensure price stability” in the event of  “renewed financial market tensions.”

As to whether intervention is likely, analysts remain divided. “The timing [for intervention] would certainly be perfect, with liquidity very thin….pre-holiday markets are ideal for springing a surprise,” said one strategist. According to Morgan Stanley, however, the SNB is “unlikely to intervene in the near term to stem the rise in the franc. The previous intervention earlier this year has left a huge overhang of liquidity in the economy and the Swiss National Bank doesn’t want to further boost the money supply.” In addition, the SNB experienced losses of €22 Billion on its forex reserves in the first nine months of this year, and will be reluctant to incur further losses by resuming intervention.

In short, aside from this lone point of uncertainty, all factors point to continued upside.

View the original article here

Euro Follows Broader Markets as Europe Attempts to Sort Out Problems

EUR/USD

The EUR/USD failed to hold onto earlier gains generated by broader risk appetite as concerns over the European debt crisis and the U.S. economy spark a late sell off. Optimism was high overnight as the Obama administration and the GOP agreed to extend unemployment benefits and extend existing tax cuts the wealthy. Risk appetite remains a main driver of the pair’s price action despite the concern over Ireland, Spain and Portugal, evidence by the 64% correlation between it and the Dow. Meanwhile, U.S. and European yield expectations have started to grow in influence with both explaining 20% of direction. Fed QE has raised concerns over future inflation and has markets starting to price in abrupt tightening. Conversely, an increase in ECB stimulus efforts has dimmed the yield outlook for the single currency. The passing of the new Irish budget failed to help generate bullish sentiment, which will leave us to take our cues from broader trends when trading the euro/dollar.

EUR Interest Rate Expectations

USD Interest Rate Expectations

ECB Interest Rate Expectations

The European Central Bank has aggressively resumed their bond purchases as they look to restore investor confidence in European sovereign debt. Meanwhile, E.U. ministers voted to not provide aid packages for Spain and Portugal as there is confidence that the monetary authority’s actions will negate the need for help. The central bank increasing their additional measures has pushed out the horizon for a rate hike with Overnight Index Swaps now pricing in 32.4 bps in tightening over the next versus 49.6 on November 18th. Discuss this and trading ideas join the EUR/USD forum.

Credit Suisse (OIS) ECB

Source Bloomberg – Prepared by John Rivera

FOMC Interest Rate Expectations

The outlook for U.S. interest rates has remained unchanged for the past month despite a dismal labor report and the ongoing issues in Europe. Talk of additional QE from Ben Bernanke also failed to dim the outlook for a rate hike, as the prospect for more pump priming has only fueled inflation fears. The upcoming economic docket is light but we could see the extension of unemployment benefits add to the prospect for future tightening. However with the FOMC rate decision looming markets may wait ti see what policy makers say before making any new bets.

Source Bloomberg – Prepared by John Rivera

Risk

Stocks ended the day flat following their late selloff after the S&P 500 hit a two year high and the Dow just missed its yearly high. The blue chip index could be settling into a short-term range if we see continued bearish momentum. 11,000 remains a major support barrier and another test of the psychological level could be ahead, which doesn’t bode well for EUR/USD bulls given their strong correlation. Discuss this and other fundamental data in the Economics Forum.

Dow (Daily)

Source Bloomberg – Prepared by John Rivera

To discuss this report or be added to the email list contact John Rivera, Currency Analyst: jrivera@fxcm.com

View the original article here

FOREX: Euro Hopes for Lifeline as All Eyes Turn to the ECB

By Ilya Spivak, Currency Strategist Thu Dec 02 06:28:00 GMT 2010 Key Overnight Developments

NZ Dollar Outperforms as Stocks Rise on US Reports, ECB Hopes Australian Dollar Misses Risk Rally on Soft Retail Sales, Trade Data Critical Levels

The Euro continued to follow the risky asset complex higher in overnight trade, adding 0.2 percent against the US Dollar. The British Pound yielded a flat result, oscillating in a narrow range above the 1.5600 figure. We remain long the US Dollar against the Euro, Kiwi and Japanese Yen.

Asia Session Highlights

Capital Spending excl Software (3Q)

Trade Balance (Australian dollar) (OCT)

The New Zealand Dollar outperformed once again in overnight trade, adding 0.6 percent on average against its top counterparts as Asian stock exchanges followed Wall Street higher, boosting the risk-correlated currency. The MSCI Asia Pacific regional benchmark index rose 1.5 percent – the most in nearly a month – following an encouraging set of US economic data as well as amid speculation that the European Central Bank may announce new measures to snuff the sovereign debt crisis festering in the Euro Zone at the upcoming monetary policy meeting (see below).

As yesterday, the Australian Dollar failed to share in the risk-driven advance, yielding a largely flat result on the session after October’s Retail Sales report proved disappointing. Receipts fell 1.1 percent, marking the first decline in eight months and the largest since July 2009. The Trade Balance surplus widened, but the outcome failed to excite considering it came courtesy of a drop in imports rather than robust export growth. Inbound shipments fell A$558 million – or 2.5 percent – while overseas sales added A$253 million (1.1 percent).

On balance, it’s no surprise the Kiwi is overtaking its antipodean counterpart as the go-to beneficiary of risk appetite. The Reserve Bank of Australia has turned noticeably timid – with markets are betting on no further rate hikes for the next 12 months – while the RBNZ is tipped to add 58bps to benchmark borrowing costs over the same period according to a Credit Suisse gauge of traders’ priced-in expectations.

Euro Session: What to Expect

French ILO Mainland Unemployment Rate (3Q)

French Mainland Unemployment Change (3Q)

French ILO Unemployment Rate (3Q)

Gross Domestic Product (YoY) (3Q)

Gross Domestic Product (QoQ) (3Q)

Retail Sales (Real) (YoY) (OCT)

Purchasing Manager Index Construction (NOV)

Euro-Zone Gross Domestic Product s.a. (QoQ) (3Q P)

Euro-Zone Gross Domestic Product s.a. (YoY) (3Q P)

Euro-Zone Household Consumption (QoQ) (3Q P)

Euro-Zone Gross Fixed Capital (QoQ) (3Q P)

Euro-Zone Government Expenditure (QoQ) (3Q P)

Euro-Zone Producer Price Index (MoM) (OCT)

Euro-Zone Producer Price Index (YoY) (OCT)

European Central Bank Rate Decision (DEC)

The monetary policy announcement from the European Central Bank takes top billing on a busy calendar of scheduled event risk, with investors hoping for bold action to contain sovereign stress on the edges of the currency bloc after a story in the Financial Times suggested Jean-Claude Trichet and company may increase their purchases of periphery bonds, thereby lowering borrowing costs and boosting liquidity. Furthermore, if the amount of renewed purchases is sufficiently large, this would markets that the ECB is confident enough in Europe’s ability to contain the crisis to risk a sovereign default against itself, an unequivocally bold statement that would likely send the Euro as well as the entire risky asset complex higher.

On balance, such an outcome seems unlikely. The ECB has given no indication that it was prepared to commit to expanding its balance sheet and several of its members (including Axel Weber, the likely candidate to succeed Trichet as the bank’s President next year) have publicly expressed their unease with the modest bond purchases already being undertaken. Furthermore, the ECB is notoriously incremental and slow-moving in its approach to monetary policy, hinting that a smaller step, like pausing the unwinding of its emergency long-term lending facilities (LTROs) for Euro Zone banks, are likely to come first. Indeed, the ECB may opt for a still more cautious approach, whereby LTROs are kept in place for the banks of those countries still under stress while phasing out those for other Euro Zone members as scheduled.

Elsewhere on the docket, the second revision of Euro Zone Gross Domestic Product figures is expected to confirm that output added 0.4 percent in the third quarter. Separately, Swiss GDP is forecast to grow 0.5 percent in the three months to September while the UK Construction PMI report shows the home-building sector slowed for the second consecutive month in November.

For real time news and analysis, please visit http://www.dailyfx.com/real_time_news

To receive future articles by email, please contact Ilya at ispivak@dailyfx.com

DailyFX provides forex news on the economic reports and political events that influence the currency market.
Learn currency trading with a free practice account and charts from FXCM.

Thu Dec 02 06:28:00 GMT 2010

// SET PAGE PROPERTIESvar sProperties = new Object();sProperties.server = '2.6';sProperties.channel = 'Fundamental: Euro Open'; // Pass page properties to Omnitureif (typeof sProperties != 'undefined') {for (var sProperty in sProperties) {s[sProperty] = sProperties[sProperty];}}var s_code=s.t(); if(s_code) document.write(s_code);

View the original article here

FOREX: Euro Threatened as Irish Government Faces Election Loss

Key Overnight Developments

Swiss Franc Underperforms as Korea Conflict Fears Subside Australian Dollar Weaker as Prices Retrace NY Session Gains Japan’s Trade Balance Surplus Widens as Imports Soften Critical Levels

The Euro and the British Pound kept to narrow ranges in Asian trade, with sterling spiking higher only late into the session after the Bank of England’s Andrew Sentence – the standby hawk on the rate-setting MPC committee – said policymakers need to gradually raise interest rates. We remain long the US Dollar against the Euro, Japanese Yen and New Zealand Dollar.

Asia Session Highlights

Corporate Service Price (YoY) (OCT)

Merchandise Trade Balance Total (Yen) (OCT)

Adjusted Merchandise Trade Balance (Yen) (OCT)

Merchandise Trade Exports (YoY) (OCT)

Merchandise Trade Imports (YoY) (OCT)

BOJ’s Nakamura Speaks on Japanese Economy

Private Capital Expenditure (3Q)

Currency markets saw quiet trade in overnight hours, with the Swiss Franc underperforming the majors having surged earlier in the week as geopolitical fears eased amid fading concerns about an escalation of violence between the Koreas. The Australian Dollar also tipped lower, retracing some of its recent gains having followed Wall Street higher in North American trade.

Japan’s Merchandise Trade Balance surplus undershot expectations, printing at 821.9 billion yen in October. While this marks an improvement in the headline reading from the previous month, the outcome seems far from encouraging considering it comes courtesy of the weakest import growth in 10 months as opposed to robust overseas sales. Indeed, exports grew at an annual pace of just 7.8 percent, the weakest since November 2009. Given strongest Yen in over a decade, which ought to boost imports, such dismal figures seem to point to little more than the anemic state of Japanese domestic demand, reinforcing deflationary pressure and keeping the perennial low-yielder’s funding currency status firmly intact for the foreseeable future.

Euro Session: What to Expect

French Consumer Confidence Indicator (NOV)

Italian Business Confidence (NOV)

All eyes are focused on Ireland, with the ruling Fianna Fáil party expected to do poorly in a by-election in Donegal South West. This would reduce the government’s majority in the lower house of parliament (the Dáil) from three to two seats, making the possibility that the current administration will lose support before the budget vote on December 7 more likely. While the markets have arguably priced in the loss already considering it has been well-telegraphed in recent polls, a particularly skewed outcome in favor of the opposition may stoke risk aversion and compound selling pressure on the Euro.

The data docket looks lackluster, with third-quarter Swiss Employment figures amounting to the only bit of notable event risk. Turning to sentiment, stock index futures tracking the major European bourses are ticking higher ahead of the opening bell, hinting risk-correlated currencies may find a bit of support, absent shocking news out of Ireland of course.

For real time news and analysis, please visit http://www.dailyfx.com/real_time_news

To receive future articles by email, please contact Ilya at ispivak@dailyfx.com

View the original article here

Forex: Euro, British Pound To Face Headwinds As Risks For Contagion Intensify

By David Song, Currency Analyst Mon Nov 22 12:30:00 GMT 2010 Talking Points

Japanese Yen: Higher Against Most Majors British Pound: Stands Ready To Aid Ireland Euro: Risks For Contagion Gathers Pace U.S. Dollar: Chicago Fed Index on Tap The Euro fell back from a high of 1.3785 during the overnight trade as Ireland opted to seek a bailout from the EU, and the single-currency may face increased headwinds going into the North American trade as the risks for contagion intensify. In response to the bailout, Moody’s Investor Services said that Ireland is likely to face a “multi-notch” downgrade, while European policy makers argued that it’s still premature to speculate on the size of the rescue package. In an effort to stem the risks for contagion, the EU announced that Portugal’s banking system is healthy and resilient, but went onto say that the euro-area continues to face an uneven recovery as the governments operating under the fixed-exchange rate system struggle to manage their public finances.

At the same time, European Union Economic and Monetary Commissioner Olli Rehn said that the issues Portugal faces are “very different” than Ireland’s as the country “has taken very bold decisions concerning fiscal consolidation and continuing its structural reforms,” but the risks for contagion could lead the European Central Bank to support the economy going into 2011 as it aims to balance the risks for the region. As fears surrounding the debt crisis exacerbates, the ECB may put its primary mandate on the line as it aims to restore financial stability, and speculation surrounding the outlook for monetary policy could play an increased role in driving price action for the euro as the central bank talks of reestablishing its exit strategy in the coming months. As the EUR/USD continues to hold below the 20-Day SMA at 1.3810, the euro-dollar may pare the rebound from the 50.0% Fibonacci retracement from the 2009 high to the 2010 low around 1.3490-1.3500, which could lead to a test of the August high (1.3333) in the coming days.

The British Pound pared the overnight rally to 1.6083 as the U.K. pledged to assist Ireland, and fears surrounding the European debt crisis could drag on the exchange rate as Britain struggles to manage its own public finances. U.K. Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne said that he stands ready to help the “friend in need” while speaking on the BBC radio, and went onto say that the U.K. has made “a commitment for a bilateral loan” in an effort to ease the turmoil in the European financial system. As the U.K. aims to curb its budget deficit and tightens fiscal policy, there could be increased pressures on the Bank of England to support the economy in 2011, but the stickiness in price growth could spur an increased split within the MPC as policy makers expect inflation to hold above target throughout the following year. As the economic outlook remains clouded with uncertainties, the GBP/USD may work its way back towards the 50-Day SMA (1.5874) to test for near-term support, but we should see the exchange rate push higher throughout the remainder of the year as it maintains the upward trend from May.

U.S. dollar price action was mixed overnight, with the USD/JPY bouncing back to reach a high of 83.56 on Monday, and we may see a clear trend develop during the North American trade as equity futures point to a lower open for the U.S. market. As the economic docket remains fairly light for Monday, risk sentiment is likely to dictate price action in the currency market, and we may see little reaction to the Chicago Fed’s National Activity index, which is expected to increase to -0.24 in October from -0.58 in the previous month, as speculation surrounding Ireland’s bailout takes center stage.

Will the EUR/USD Retrace The Advance From September As European Debt Woes Intensify? Join us in the Forum

Related Articles: Forex Weekly Trading Forecast - 11.15.10

To discuss this report contact David Song, Currency Analyst:dsong@fxcm.com

FX Upcoming

Chicago Fed National Activity Index (OCT)

Euro-Zone Consumer Confidence (NOV A)

ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet Delivers Annual Report

Fed's Narayana Kocherlakota Speaks on Monetary Policy

New Zealand Net Migration s.a. (OCT)

Contracts for 23 straight months.

Convenience Store Sales (YoY) (OCT)

Falls for first time in three-months.

Slowest rate of growth since April.

DailyFX provides forex news on the economic reports and political events that influence the currency market.
Learn currency trading with a free practice account and charts from FXCM.

Mon Nov 22 12:30:00 GMT 2010

// SET PAGE PROPERTIESvar sProperties = new Object();sProperties.server = '2.6';sProperties.channel = 'Fundamental: US Open'; // Pass page properties to Omnitureif (typeof sProperties != 'undefined') {for (var sProperty in sProperties) {s[sProperty] = sProperties[sProperty];}}var s_code=s.t(); if(s_code) document.write(s_code);

View the original article here

Kiwi Stands Out in Early Monday Trade; Euro Bid on EU/IMF Bailout

An interesting and exciting start to the week, with currencies trading all over the place and in different directions on the back of varying market drivers. The Euro has jumped out to some early gains on Monday with the weekend news of an EU and IMF bailout for Ireland of some Eur80-90B helping to bolster sentiment in the region. However, there are those who feel that the need for the bailout should be viewed as more of a net negative, with fears now spreading to other beleaguered economies within the Eurozone. Much of the attention from those with such views has no shifted over to Portugal, and it will be interesting to see how things play out and if indeed the Euro can sustain the positive momentum from the bailout news.

We continue to find it quite amusing that we now live in a world where news that recognizes major setbacks within the global economy is recognized with a positive sentiment reaction. Whether it is the latest bailout of Ireland, or the announcement from the Fed of more quantitative easing, the markets continue to translate these distressing actions as risk positive which continues to leave us highly concerned and distraught.

Another big story on the day has come out of New Zealand, with Kiwi getting slammed across the board following the news that S&P has revised its foreign currency sovereign debt outlook from “stable” to “negative.” The rating agency cited New Zealand’s “vulnerability to external shocks, arising from its open and relatively undiversified economy” as the main source for its concern. Interestingly enough, we have gone ahead and initiated a position in the Kiwi, but our position is long Kiwi against the Australian Dollar.

The Aud/Nzd cross has jumped well over 200 points on the day to more than double its average daily true range, leaving the hourly RSI above 80. This suggests that at a minimum we should see some form of a corrective move following the parabolic price action, and as such, the short trade makes sense. Fundamentally, New Zealand’s banking sector is largely owned by Australian banks and we contend that any fallout in New Zealand from the rating agencies could very well be a red flag for the Australian economy. Recent tightening actions in China should also not be ignored, and Australia is far more exposed to the fallout from such actions which ultimately will curb growth and force a material slowdown in the overdone Australian economy. This further supports our current Aud/Nzd short position.

Looking ahead, the European session is very quiet on the economic release front, with the only noteworthy data series coming in the form of some Swiss money supply due at 8:00GMT. Eurozone consumer confidence (-10 expected) is due out in North American trade at 15:00GMT, but not before the release of the only US data in the form of the Chicago national Fed activity index at 13:30GMT. On the official circuit, ECB President Trichet delivers his annual report at 15:00GMT, while Fed Kocherlakota speaks in South Dakota at 18:30GMT. US equity futures and commodities prices are fairly well bid on the day.

Written by Joel Kruger, Technical Currency Strategist

If you wish to receive Joel’s reports in a more timely fashion, email jskruger@fxcm.com and you will be added to the distribution list.

If you wish to discuss this or any other topic feel free to visit our Forum Page.

View the original article here